Cardano’s delegated representatives have rejected Toto Finance’s request for 22 million ADA from the network treasury to buy physical copper, with the governance action expiring on November 15 after overwhelming opposition.

Summary

  • Cardano representatives rejected Toto Finance’s 22 million ADA copper proposal after opposition exceeded support by more than 140 to one.
  • The proposal received only 0.51% DRep support, while none of the seven Constitutional Committee members approved it.
  • Toto planned to spend 14.72 million ADA on copper, with the remaining funds covering technology, operations and oversight.
  • DReps questioned the proposed fees, unfinished custody protections and the risk of losing treasury funds through commodity investments.
  • Rejecting the request preserved roughly 42.6 million ADA in remaining spending capacity under Cardano’s current 500 million ADA withdrawal limit.

Cardanoscan’s governance record shows approximately 20.02 million ADA supporting the proposal, against 2.86 billion ADA explicitly voting no. Another 131.29 million ADA was assigned to no-confidence, while the proposal drew just 0.51% support under the tracker’s counted-stake calculation. None of the seven Constitutional Committee members approved the request, with three voting against its constitutionality and four not voting.

Cardano Copper Reserve Proposal Fails Governance Threshold

Submitted on October 15, Toto Finance’s proposal sought a one-time treasury withdrawal to create a strategic reserve of physical copper. Delegated representatives, or DReps, vote using ADA delegated by token holders, with voting power determined by stake instead of the number of individual accounts.

Treasury withdrawals require 67% support from counted DRep voting power and approval from the Constitutional Committee. Toto’s request secured neither. Under Intersect’s governance rules, proposals become ratified once both requirements are satisfied, with treasury funds transferred at a subsequent epoch boundary. The expired copper proposal resulted in no withdrawal.

Opposing DRep stake outnumbered supporting stake by more than 140 to one. Five DReps voted yes, compared with 126 explicit no votes, according to the on-chain record.

Toto Finance Planned to Store Copper and Issue Tokens

The project, named the Cardano Strategic Copper Reserve, would have purchased COMEX Grade 1 copper cathodes and stored them in an approved US warehouse. Its proposed CuTT token would represent one verified pound of copper, supported by warehouse documentation and reserve reporting.

Toto planned to issue the original CuTT tokens as ERC-20 assets on Ethereum, lock the treasury-funded portion in escrow and circulate corresponding bridged tokens on Cardano. The arrangement drew criticism from DReps who questioned why a Cardano treasury-financed project needed Ethereum issuance and a cross-chain bridge.

The funding proposal allocated 14.72 million ADA, or 66.93% of the withdrawal, to buying copper. Another 2.64 million ADA was assigned to technology and management, 3.53 million to operations and assurance, 441,732 to execution, and 660,000 to independent oversight.

Under the plan, the metal would remain in storage for 18 to 24 months before a controlled sale. Toto intended to return the net proceeds and unused budgets to Cardano’s treasury within 36 months, without guaranteeing recovery of the original ADA.

DReps Question Fees, Custody and Investment Risks

The budget meant less than two-thirds of the treasury allocation would actually purchase metal. At unchanged ADA exchange rates and with all proposed cost allowances used, copper would need to appreciate roughly 49% before its sale proceeds could recover the original 22 million ADA, based on Toto’s calculations.

The proposal acknowledged that recovery of the original principal or profit was not guaranteed. It identified copper price movements, exchange-rate changes, custody failures and potential cross-chain bridge problems among the financial risks.

Several safeguards remained conditions for implementation. Toto identified a US member firm of PwC as its preferred independent oversight provider but had not engaged one. The plan called for the treasury withdrawal to enter a Toto-controlled receiving account before subsequent independent protections were established.

JohnM, a DRep who opposed the request, raised concerns about the funding arrangement.

“I am voting No because the money arrives before any of the protections do,” he wrote in his voting rationale.

Other representatives questioned whether communal funds should support a private commodity investment.

“This is a business/financial venture and should be financed by risk capital, not public monies,” opposing DRep Mike Rogero wrote in his published voting rationale.

crypto.news contacted Toto Finance for comment on the proposal’s rejection and concerns surrounding its fees and custody arrangements but did not receive a response by press time.

Cardano Treasury Retains Remaining Spending Capacity

The rejected request would have used more than half the remaining allowance under Cardano’s 500 million ADA spending limit, which runs through approximately July 2027.

DRepTalk’s treasury tracker lists 457.4 million ADA already withdrawn during the period, leaving 42.6 million ADA available under the cap. Toto’s request represented approximately 51.6% of that remaining capacity.

The cap limits withdrawals, not the network’s entire treasury balance. As previously covered in October, Cardano had already used more than 91% of its spending allowance.

At ADA’s November 16 market price near $0.15, the proposed withdrawal was worth roughly $3.3 million, below the nearly $5 million valuation used when the proposal was initially discussed.

Cardano’s governance community has rejected major funding requests before. In June, a 7.8 million ADA proposal for its annual summit failed despite attracting 65.2% support, as crypto.news reported. A separate 32.9 million ADA request for Input Output Global’s research laboratory encountered opposition from representatives controlling most of the participating stake.

Other spending requests remain under consideration. Trivolve Tech has proposed 9.6 million ADA for a police evidence management system in India, with voting scheduled to close November 20. Cardano’s October Project Catalyst selection separately backed 12 projects from 117 applications under a 2 million ADA funding program.



Source link


author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *